Tropicana Saga


Exhibit 24.2   Tropicana debacle — new packaging (right) led to a 20% slump in sales.

One of the great shortcomings of marketers is the tendency to discard something of great value for the wrong reasons. It happens all the time but some tales are more noteworthy than others.

In January of 2009, PepsiCo revamped the packaging of Tropicana. The vivid and memorable orange-with-straw-poking-out graphic was discarded. It was replaced with the glass of juice version shown in Exhibit 24.2.

The outcome was far from what PepsiCo had hoped for. According to IRI’s Infoscan, sales of the Tropicana Pure Premium plummeted 20% from Jan 1 and Feb. 22. And on Feb 23, the company announced that they would bring back the old packaging.

Undoubtedly talented marketers and designers devoted time and attention to this USD 35 million campaign. Yet, considering the scale of market impact, the high level of dissonance should have been sensed through consumer research. If decisions were guided by research, PepsiCo might not have lost an estimated over hundred million dollars in sales.

Though reminiscent of the New Coke launch, the Tropicana debacle is distinct in that it centred mainly on packaging. The saga explicitly illustrates the pivotal role that packaging can play in driving sales and building brand equity.

It also highlights the importance of testing and optimizing packaging, and understanding how it works.

Previous     Next

Note: To find content on MarketingMind type the acronym ‘MM’ followed by your query into the search bar. For example, if you enter ‘mm consumer analytics’ into Chrome’s search bar, relevant pages from MarketingMind will appear in Google’s result pages.







What they SHOULD TEACH at Business Schools

What they SHOULD TEACH at Business Schools


Is marketing education fluffy too?


Experiential Learning via Simulators | Best Way to Train Marketers

Experiential Learning via Simulators | Best Way to Train Marketers


Marketing simulators impart much needed combat experiences, equipping practitioners with the skills to succeed in the consumer market battleground. They combine theory with practice, linking the classroom with the consumer marketplace.